Patagonia Guidewater Backpack 25L vs. Roll-Top Pack 41L Review

There are two kinds of anglers:

those who have drowned a phone, and those who haven’t yet.

A waterproof backpack is the cheapest insurance policy in fly fishing. It’s the thing that keeps your camera, your spare layer and your car keys dry when the rain sets in for the afternoon, when a wade goes half a step too deep, or when the boat ride back turns into a spray-soaked slog. Patagonia’s answer is the new Guidewater line – and it comes in two flavors that look almost identical from behind but make very different promises once you open them. The Guidewater Backpack 25L closes with a waterproof zip and is fully submersible. The Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L trades the zip for a classic dry-bag roll closure and gives you sixty percent more space for less money. We carried both through a cold, wet autumn day on the river to find out which one deserves a place on your back.

Disclaimer: Some of the links in this article are affiliate links. If you click on one of them and end up purchasing a product we earn a small commission at no extra cost for you. We only recommend products we believe in ourselves. Learn more here.

Angler wading through river rapids wearing the Patagonia Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L with a rod tube
The Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L out on the river on a wet autumn day

Overview: Same Pack, Two Closures

The two Guidewater packs are siblings in the most literal sense. They are built from the same fabric, ride on the same harness and carry the same list of fishing-specific features. Where they split is the closure – and that one decision changes the capacity, the level of waterproofing, the weight and the price.

800-Denier Recycled Nylon: Both bodies are made from an 18-oz, 800-denier, 100% recycled nylon plain weave, TPU-coated front and back. That’s a heavy, slick fabric that wipes clean, shrugs off sharp rock and doesn’t soak up water. It’s the same family of material Patagonia has been using on its waterproof fishing packs for years, and it’s the reason those older packs tend to outlive their owners’ waders.

Waterproof Ratings: This is the key difference. The 25L zip pack is IPX-7 rated, which means it’s waterproof and submersible – Patagonia specifies up to one metre of depth for 30 minutes. The 41L roll-top is IPX-6 rated: watertight in sustained heavy rain and spray, sealing out water up to the roll-top closure, but not designed to go under.

Harness and Back Panel: Both use a recycled polyester spacer mesh back panel and shoulder straps (bluesign® approved), plus a removable, padded hip belt for heavier loads and longer walks.

Fair Trade Certified: Both packs are made in a Fair Trade Certified™ factory in Vietnam.

Three Torso Sizes: Unusually for a fishing pack, both come in Small, Medium and Large, with the height of the bag growing with the size. That’s a genuinely useful detail – a pack that’s too long for your torso sits on your hips and rubs on your wader belt all day.

Patagonia Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L standing open on a riverbank with a Hardy rod tube attached
The roll-top opens into one big, uncomplicated bucket
Patagonia Guidewater Backpack 25L lying in riverside vegetation with a Loop rod tube attached
The zip-closing Guidewater Backpack 25L

Size and Specs Compared

Guidewater Backpack 25LGuidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L
Price$349$289
Capacity25 L (1,526 cu in)41 L (2,502 cu in)
ClosureWaterproof zipRoll-top with buckle
Waterproof ratingIPX-7 – waterproof and submersible (1 m / 30 min)IPX-6 – watertight up to the roll-top, not submersible
Weight1,300 g (2 lb 13.9 oz)1,550 g (3 lb 6.7 oz)
Dimensions (S / M / L)13 × 6 × 19 / 21 / 23 in13 × 7 × 21 / 23 / 25 in
Fabric800D recycled nylon, TPU-coated both sides800D recycled nylon, TPU-coated both sides
Hip beltRemovable, paddedRemovable, padded
Net scabbardIntegrated, left- or right-handedIntegrated, left- or right-handed
Rod holdersYesYes

Numbers from Patagonia. The interesting line is the price: the bigger pack is the cheaper one. What you’re paying the extra $60 for on the 25L is the submersible zip.

The Details That Make Them Fishing Packs

Rod Holders: Two rubberized strap holders on the side lock a rod tube to the pack. We ran a full-length Hardy tube on the roll-top and a Loop tube on the zip pack, and both stayed put through a long walk and plenty of scrambling along the bank. With the tube on your back, your hands are free for the net, the rod you’re actually fishing, or the hand you’ll need when the bank gives way. Both backpacks are definitely designed for right handed casters though.

Back view of the Patagonia Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L with a black rod tube in the side straps
A full-length rod tube on the roll-top…
Back view of the Patagonia Guidewater Backpack 25L with a white Loop rod tube in the side straps
…and on the 25L zip pack

Integrated Net Scabbard: A sleeve built into the back panel takes a landing net, set up for left- or right-handed anglers. It keeps the net out of the way while walking and in reach when a fish is on.

Lash Points and Modularity: Both packs have multiple lash points to carry one of Patagonia’s 3- or 5-litre Stealth Switch Packs, plus an external bottle carrier. Both are also compatible with the Convertible Vest and the Stealth Switch Packs, so you can run the backpack as your dry storage and keep flies, tippet and nippers on your chest.

Tool Docks and Key Clip: Docks on the shoulder straps hold pliers or nippers, and an internal zippered pocket with a key clip stops the car key from disappearing into the bottom of the bag.

Daisy Chains: Two webbing loops run down the front of both packs for a jacket, a wading staff or anything else that’s wet and doesn’t need to go inside.

Function: Zip or Roll?

Guidewater Backpack 25L: The Submersible Option

The 25L’s party piece is its waterproof zip, which runs across the top and down one side of the bag. Unzipped, the main compartment opens wide, so you can get to a camera or a fly box without unpacking everything above it. Zipped, it’s sealed to IPX-7 – the level at which the pack can go fully underwater for a short time without anything getting wet. If you fish from a drift boat or a pontoon, wade big rivers, or ever cross water above your waist, that’s the difference between a soggy afternoon and a ruined camera.

Side view of the Patagonia Guidewater Backpack 25L showing the waterproof zip running down the side
The heavy waterproof zip runs over the top and down the side
Angler carrying the Patagonia Guidewater Backpack 25L by its top handle with a Loop rod tube attached
Compact enough to grab by the handle and go

The trade-off is that a waterproof zip is stiff. It takes two hands and a bit of effort to open and close, and it has to be looked after – rinsed after saltwater and lubricated now and then – or it will get harder to pull over time. At 25 liters, it’s a day pack: a camera, a spare insulating layer, lunch, a flask and a couple of fly boxes, and you’re about full.

Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L: The Load Carrier

The 41L is the more straightforward bag. Roll the top down, clip the buckle, and the inside stays dry through as much rain as an autumn day on the river can throw at it. There’s no zip to service and nothing to jam, and because the closure adjusts to the load, the bag compresses when it’s half empty and grows when it’s stuffed. Sixty percent more capacity than the 25L means a full wader-and-boots kit, a camera with a spare lens, or the extra layers you’ll want for a long, cold day out.

Close-up back view of the Patagonia Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L in the rain with the roll-top closed
Roll it down, clip it, forget about the weather
Side view of an angler wearing the Patagonia Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L with a rod tube
From the side, the roll-top sits deep and tall

The catch is in the rating. IPX-6 means waterproof against heavy rain and spray, not submersion. Fall in with this on your back, and the roll-top closure is where water can find its way in. Roll-tops are also slower to get into – it takes a few seconds to unclip and unroll, and the thing you want is always at the bottom.

Style: Quiet Patagonia

Both packs share the same quiet look: a muted, sage-grey body, a small printed Patagonia logo running vertically down the front, tan webbing and a bright blue mesh back panel that only shows when the pack comes off. Patagonia offers both in Forge Grey and River Rock Green. Against waxed cotton or a dark shell, they look at home on the river and not out of place on a train.

The silhouettes are different, though. The 25L is a clean, rounded slab that sits close to your back, almost like a city daypack. The roll-top, with its folded crown and buckle across the top, has the more classic dry-bag look – and with a rod tube strapped to its side, it gives off unmistakable expedition energy.

In the Wild: Performance Review

Angler wading a wide misty river wearing the Patagonia Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L
Fishing a big river with the roll-top on

Carrying

With the same harness, the two packs feel similar on the shoulders. The spacer mesh back panel is firm enough to spread the load and doesn’t hold water the way foam does. On a long walk to the lower pools, the 25L is the one you forget about – it rides higher and closer to your body. Fully loaded, the 41L is noticeably more pack, and that’s when the removable hip belt earns its place.

Keeping the Weather Out

We carried both through hours of steady autumn rain, and nothing came through either bag. Water beaded on the TPU-coated fabric and ran off; the inside of both packs stayed dry. In rain, the IPX-6 roll-top is every bit as good as the IPX-7 zip. The difference only matters when the pack goes under.

Fishing With It On

Both packs are slim enough to cast with on your back, and neither shifted around while wading. The rod holders are the standout – once you’ve walked a long bank with a rod tube strapped to your pack rather than tucked under your arm, it’s hard to go back.

Angler wading with fly line in hand wearing the Patagonia Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L
Slim enough to fish with on your back

Which One Should You Buy?

Get the Guidewater Backpack 25L if you fish from boats, wade deep, fish saltwater, or carry gear that can’t survive a dunking – a camera above all. It’s also the better choice if you like getting into your bag quickly and fish in shorter sessions where 25 litres is enough.

Get the Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L if you need space – for travel days, long hikes into remote water, carrying waders and boots, or a day on the water in cold weather with a full set of layers. If your main enemy is rain rather than the river, the roll-top delivers the same dry contents for $60 less.

Pros and Cons

Guidewater Backpack 25L

PROS:

  • IPX-7 rated: waterproof and submersible
  • Wide-opening zip gives fast access to the main compartment
  • Compact profile that’s easy to fish with
  • Integrated net scabbard, rod holders and modular lash points

CONS:

  • $349 is steep for a 25-litre pack
  • Stiff waterproof zip needs two hands and regular care
  • 25 litres fills up quickly on long or cold days

Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L

PROS:

  • 41 litres of dry storage for $60 less than the 25L
  • Simple roll-top with no zip to service or jam
  • Expands and compresses with the load
  • Same harness and fishing features as the 25L

CONS:

  • IPX-6 only: not designed to be submerged
  • Slower to get into than a zip
  • At 1,550 g, the heavier of the two

The Verdict

Angler wading in a fast river seen through riverside foliage, wearing the Patagonia Guidewater pack

The Patagonia Guidewater packs are two very good bags built around one honest question: how wet does your gear get? If the answer is “rained on,” the Roll-Top Pack 41L is the better buy – more space, fewer moving parts and a lower price. If the answer is “occasionally underwater,” the Guidewater Backpack 25L justifies its premium with a submersible zip that keeps everything dry, even when you don’t. Either way, the shared harness, rod holders and net scabbard make these two of the most thoughtfully designed waterproof fishing packs we’ve used.

GET THE GUIDEWATER BACKPACK 25L AT PATAGONIA

GET THE GUIDEWATER ROLL-TOP PACK 41L AT PATAGONIA

Frequently Asked Questions: Patagonia Guidewater Packs

Is the Patagonia Guidewater Backpack 25L submersible?

Yes. It’s IPX-7 rated, and Patagonia specifies it as waterproof up to one metre of depth for 30 minutes.

Is the Guidewater Roll-Top Pack 41L fully waterproof?

It’s IPX-6 rated, meaning it stays watertight in sustained heavy rain and spray, sealing out water up to the roll-top closure. It is not designed to be submerged.

What’s the difference between the Guidewater 25L and the 41L?

The closure. The 25L has a waterproof zip and is submersible; the 41L has a roll-top, is not submersible, holds 16 litres more and costs $60 less. Fabric, harness and fishing features are the same.

How much do the Guidewater packs weigh?

Patagonia lists the 25L at 1,300 g (2 lb 13.9 oz) and the 41L at 1,550 g (3 lb 6.7 oz).

Do the Guidewater packs come in different sizes?

Yes. Both are offered in Small, Medium and Large torso sizes, with the bag getting taller with each size.

Can I attach a rod tube to the Guidewater packs?

Yes. Both have side-mounted rod holders that take a full-length rod tube.

+ posts

Leonard Schoenberger is a fly fishing professional and gear specialist with over 20 years of experience on the water. As the manager of Heidarvatn, a world-class sea trout lodge in Iceland, his product recommendations and tactical advice are tested in some of the most demanding conditions on earth. His expertise has been mentioned in The New York Times, the Financial Times, and at the Outdoor Media Summit.